Posts/#society

On Secret Knowledge

Let’s imagine I became the ruler of a country and wanted to keep certain knowledge from the public. Not necessarily secret knowledge — more the kind that lets us get to the heart of things, understand their root causes and gain certain advantages along the way.

How would I go about it?

I certainly wouldn’t ban anything. Forbidden fruit is sweet, as the saying goes. The stricter the ban, the more attention it attracts. And the very act of banning something seems to say: “I’m afraid of this knowledge, so I don’t want you to have it.”

I’d take a different approach. I’d make this knowledge a laughingstock.

I’d call it pseudoscience, quackery, and make the people studying it look like the town cranks. I’d shut them out of leading universities and scientific journals, so that any attempt to discuss such a subject seriously would draw a condescending smile from respected academics.

And the best part — I wouldn’t have to ban a thing. Society would do the job perfectly well on its own. After all, few people want to look like idiots, especially when their reputation and career are at stake.

Why would I bother?

Suppose there is knowledge that lets people solve their own problems. What would happen to industries built on human dependence? Who would need an endless supply of crutches and pills that treat symptoms rather than root causes? What would happen to corporations, state institutions and religious institutions whose influence depends so much on our need for their help?

Naturally, as a ruler, I’d have an interest in keeping all those machines running smoothly.

Incidentally, in my view, the phrase “evidence-based medicine” is a marketing masterpiece in its own right. It sounds as though everything else is unproven by definition, while here the truth has already been established — often by the very people who funded the research. I don’t deny the scientific value of such studies, but I don’t consider their findings impartial either.

Still, this is less about medicine than about entire bodies of human knowledge.

Where am I going with this?

The next time we come across something we’re expected to laugh at, something people around us dismiss as complete nonsense or pseudoscience, it might be worth asking: what if this is exactly what the most effective way of hiding truly valuable knowledge would look like?

Of course, that doesn’t mean every ridiculed idea contains some truth. There are plenty of charlatans and plenty of outright nonsense. But neither public recognition nor universal contempt proves anything on its own.

After all, the best way to hide knowledge is to convince people it isn’t worth their attention, rather than put it out of reach.

Here’s to not being afraid to look into things for ourselves, even the things we’re expected to laugh at! 😎

Liked this? Get the next note in your inbox.

← Back to home